Two Paths to Co-op Ownership
When searching for a Manhattan co-op, you'll encounter two distinct types of listings: resale units sold by individual shareholders, and sponsor units sold by the original building owner or developer. The distinction matters far more than most buyers realize.
Sponsor units offer unique advantages—most notably, no board approval required. But they also come with trade-offs in pricing, condition, and negotiating dynamics. Understanding these differences helps you evaluate opportunities accurately and avoid overpaying for benefits you may not need.
What Is a Sponsor Unit?
When a rental building converts to cooperative ownership, the developer or building owner (the "sponsor") retains ownership of unsold units. These sponsor-held units can be sold at any time, sometimes decades after conversion.
Sponsors might include:
- Original developers who converted the building and retained unsold inventory
- Investors who purchased sponsor positions from original developers
- Estates or trusts that inherited sponsor holdings
- Banks or institutions that acquired sponsor units through foreclosure or other transactions
The key legal distinction: sponsor units are governed by the original offering plan rather than the proprietary lease provisions that apply to resale units.
What Is a Resale Unit?
A resale unit is any apartment previously purchased from the sponsor and now being sold by an individual shareholder. The vast majority of co-op listings—probably 90% or more—are resales.
Resale purchases follow the standard co-op process: submit a board package, undergo financial review, potentially interview with board members, and receive approval before closing.
The Key Differences
Board Approval
- Sponsor units: No board approval required. The sponsor’s right to sell without board consent is preserved in the offering plan. Financial info is submitted to the managing agent, but the board cannot reject you.
- Resale units: Full board approval required. The board reviews finances, references, and background, then votes on the application. Rejection is possible for qualified buyers.
Pricing
- Sponsor units: Typically priced at a premium—often 5-15% above comparable resales.
- Resale units: Market-priced based on comparable sales, condition, and negotiation.
Condition and Renovation
- Sponsor units: Often sold in original or dated condition. Minimal renovation is done by the sponsor.
- Resale units: Condition varies widely; some renovated, some sold as-is.
| Renovation Scope |
Approximate Cost |
| Cosmetic refresh (paint, floors, fixtures) |
$50,000-100,000 |
| Kitchen renovation |
$75,000-150,000 |
| Bathroom renovation (per bath) |
$40,000-80,000 |
| Gut renovation |
$200,000-400,000+ |
Financing
- Sponsor units: Often more flexible. Lower down payments (10-15%), sometimes direct financing from sponsor.
- Resale units: Subject to building financing rules; usually 20-50% down, board approval required.
Negotiation Dynamics
- Sponsor units: Negotiating with a corporate entity. Less emotional, more transactional, often holding power.
- Resale units: Negotiating with individuals. Personal motivations, timelines, and circumstances affect pricing.
Subletting Rights
- Sponsor units: Often favorable subletting rights; check what transfers to buyer.
- Resale units: Subject to building policies; often require approval and fees.
When to Buy
Sponsor Unit
- Non-traditional finances (self-employed, freelancers, foreign nationals)
- Privacy concerns
- Planning renovation
- Subletting flexibility desired
- Speedy closing desired
Resale Unit
- Straightforward finances
- Move-in ready condition desired
- Price sensitivity
- Community vetting desired
- Scarcity of sponsor units not a factor
Due Diligence
Sponsor Units
- Review Offering Plan: Sponsor rights, risks, financing provisions, subletting rights.
- Verify Sponsor Identity: Original developer or subsequent purchaser.
- Understand Transfer of Rights: Check which privileges transfer.
- Inspect Carefully: Units sold as-is; professional inspection essential.
- Budget for Renovation: Obtain contractor estimates before finalizing.
Resale Units
- Review Board Package Requirements
- Research Board Approval History
- Verify Recent Renovations: Permits and receipts
- Understand House Rules: Subletting, pets, renovations
- Assess Seller Motivation: Estate sales, divorces, relocations affect negotiation
Comparing Total Costs
| Cost Component |
Sponsor Unit |
Resale (Renovated) |
| Purchase price |
$1,350,000 |
$1,200,000 |
| Estimated renovation |
$175,000 |
$0 |
| Total investment |
$1,525,000 |
$1,200,000 |
Alternative Scenario: Both Need Renovation
| Cost Component |
Sponsor Unit |
Resale (Original) |
| Purchase price |
$1,350,000 |
$1,250,000 |
| Estimated renovation |
$175,000 |
$175,000 |
| Total investment |
$1,525,000 |
$1,425,000 |
Questions to Ask About Any Sponsor Unit
- Who is the sponsor?
- What rights transfer to me?
- What's the unit's condition?
- Are there sponsor-specific obligations?
- How does pricing compare to recent resales?
- What financing will the sponsor accept?
- How many sponsor units remain?
- What's the sponsor's timeline?
The Bottom Line
Sponsor units and resale co-ops offer different value propositions. Sponsor units provide certainty, flexibility, and privacy at a premium. Resale units offer market pricing, move-in-ready condition, and community vetting. The best choice depends on your finances, priorities, and circumstances.
Francine Crocker helps buyers evaluate both sponsor and resale opportunities objectively, ensuring you understand exactly what you're buying.
Table of Contents →